Butt urges Manchester United to consider re-signing Everton's Garner
Former Manchester United midfielder Nicky Butt has publicly advocated for his old club to pursue a reunion with Everton's James Garner, citing the player's significant development since leaving Old Trafford. The suggestion comes as Manchester United are expected to seek midfield reinforcements this summer, with Casemiro confirmed to be departing.
Garner, 25, came through United's academy before joining Everton for a reported £15 million in 2022 after loan spells at Watford and Nottingham Forest. He has since become a pivotal figure for David Moyes's side, contributing eight goals and assists this season as Everton chase European qualification. His club form earned him a first England call-up in March, where he featured in friendlies against Uruguay and Japan.
Speaking to Paddy Power, Butt, who oversaw Garner's progress in United's youth setup, expressed strong belief in the midfielder's capabilities. "I don’t see why he couldn’t be back at United," Butt said. "He’s performing well, he’s playing for a big club with a big expectation... he knows Man United and yeah, he’s doing amazingly well now." He did caution that a move this summer might be premature, suggesting Garner needs to consistently replicate this season's form.
Butt emphasized how Garner has evolved since his departure, noting the player lacked the required level for regular first-team football at the time. "At the time Jimmy wasn’t at the level to burst into United and play regularly. It wasn’t working so quite rightly he moved on and kick-started his career," he explained. He praised Garner's drive and described him as a versatile, modern midfielder with a complete skillset, even comparing his style to a "poorer man’s version of Gerrard."
The potential transfer is complicated by Garner's importance to Everton and his recent integration into the England setup, where he has been labelled a "mini Federico Valverde" for his energetic and adaptable performances. Everton's reported confidence in securing a new contract for the player, as indicated in other recent reports, would also present a significant obstacle for any suitor.
For Manchester United, the midfield is a clear area for investment. Garner's profile as a homegrown, physically robust, and technically sound player fits the strategic model often pursued by the club's hierarchy. His ability to play in multiple midfield roles could provide valuable depth and tactical flexibility for manager Erik ten Hag. However, any move would likely require a substantial fee, far exceeding the sum Everton paid two years ago, given his contract situation and current status.
