Liverpool are grappling with internal regret over the sale of Caoimhin Kelleher and growing uncertainty over the future of first-choice goalkeeper Alisson Becker, according to sources speaking to TEAMtalk. The club sanctioned Kelleher's departure to Brentford last summer for an initial fee of £12.8 million, potentially rising to £18 million with add-ons, as his contract entered its final year. At the time, Liverpool believed they had secured a long-term successor in Giorgi Mamardashvili, signed from Valencia for £29 million.
That succession plan, however, has not progressed as smoothly as anticipated. While Mamardashvili has deputised during Alisson's injury absences this season, sources indicate the Georgian international has yet to fully convince the coaching staff he is ready to become the undisputed number one. This concern is now amplified by fresh speculation surrounding Alisson's own future at Anfield. The Brazilian, widely considered one of the world's top goalkeepers, is reportedly a target for Juventus, who are said to be preparing a lucrative long-term contract offer.
Despite Liverpool triggering a one-year extension in Alisson's deal earlier this season, the situation is understood to have evolved, with the possibility of a summer exit now being considered. This potential double departure scenario has led to internal reflection on the decision to allow Kelleher to leave. The Republic of Ireland international had established himself as a reliable and capable deputy over several seasons, making 47 appearances for the Reds and winning two League Cups, starting in both finals.
Sources suggest some within the club now view his sale as a move that may have prematurely weakened their goalkeeping depth at a critical juncture. While a sensational return for Kelleher has been mooted in some reports, it is considered highly unlikely, with Brentford boss Keith Andrews having publicly dismissed such a possibility. Instead, Liverpool are actively scouting alternative options should a major transition between the posts become necessary.
According to TEAMtalk, Porto's Diogo Costa is among a shortlist of four potential targets under consideration by the recruitment team. Another option remains to reject any approach for Alisson, prioritising stability and blocking his sale altogether. The coming months will be pivotal for Liverpool's planning, as they balance the potential of a significant fee for a 31-year-old goalkeeper against the risk of entering a new season with an unproven number one and a lack of experienced cover.
